Russians secretly denounce Putin's rally

Russians secretly denounce Putin’s ‘Billy Graham meets Kim Jong-Un’ pro-war rally: YouTube live stream is flooded with critical comments after Kremlin FORCED tens of thousands to attend by bussing them in… before they left early

Vladimir Putin gathered tens of thousands of Russians at a rally in Moscow to drum up support for Ukraine war
He gave a tub-thumping speech in which he peddled falsehoods about ‘Nazis’ in Ukraine, ‘genocide’ in the Donbass, and shilled a misleading narrative about Russia’s battlefield success
But some attendees told journalists they were government workers who had been pressured to come
Others were students who were told they could have a day off from lectures if they attended ‘a concert’
Video showed attendees outside turning their backs to reporters’ cameras in an attempt to hide their faces
Questions were also raised over the authenticity of some of the footage at the event

Vladimir Putin’s tub-thumping speech yesterday was likened to ‘Billy Graham meets North Korea’ by a Russian commentator, a reference to both the American Christian evangelist and Kim Jong-un’s propagandising rallies, while the YouTube live stream of the rally was flooded with critical comments.

Tens of thousands of flag-waving Russians packed out Moscow’s Luzhniki World Cup stadium on Friday as the despot attempted to drum up support for his stalled invasion of Ukraine, peddled debunked claims about why the war started and shilled a false narrative of Russia’s battlefield ‘success’.

However, speaking to journalists outside the stadium, some said they were government workers who had been pressured to come, and were bussed to the event. Others were students who were told they could have a day off from lectures if they attended ‘a concert’.

In one video, as a reporter attempted to film the crowds outside the stadium, attendees were seen turning their backs to the camera in an attempt to hide their faces.

Several Telegram channels critical of the Kremlin reported that students and employees of state institutions in a number of regions were ordered by their superiors to attend rallies and concerts marking the Crimea anniversary. Those reports could not be independently verified.

Meanwhile, whoever set up a live stream of the event on YouTube did not turn the comment section off, meaning thousands of negative comments towards the event – written in Russian – flooded the page, as did blue and yellow heart emojis – the colours of Ukraine’s flag.

In his speech, Putin quoted the Bible’s book of John, praising his troops in Ukraine. ‘The words from the sacred scripture come to my mind: “There is no greater love than if someone laid down his life for his friends,”‘ he said.

The event was heavily anti-Western and filled with Soviet nostalgia, as Russian authorities ramped up patriotism in response to being hit by massive international sanctions for Putin’s Ukraine campaign, which has stalled thanks to fierce resistance. Thousands of Russian soldiers have been killed.

Putin’s rally was quickly likened to similar massive marches held by North Korea’s dictator Kim Jong-Un, which are said to be attended by citizens who are given no other choice, as well as the massive evangelical rallies hosted by American minister Billy Graham in America.

One Russian commentator called the event ‘Billy Graham meets North Korea’, according to The Daily Telegraph.

In the wake of the invasion, the Kremlin has cracked down harder on dissent and the flow of information, arresting thousands of antiwar protesters, banning sites such as Facebook and Twitter, and handing out tough prison sentences for what it says is false reporting on the war, which Moscow refers to as a ‘special military operation.’

The OVD-Info rights group that monitors political arrests reported that at least seven independent journalists had been detained ahead of or while covering the anniversary events in Moscow and St. Petersburg.

There we also other signs that not was all as it seemed. There were reports on twitter suggesting some of the footage used of the rally was old footage from another video from 2021.

And a bizarre moment in the speech came when Putin suddenly disappeared from news feeds in mid-sentence – replaced by a band that was mid-way through singing, perhaps suggesting his address was not broadcast live.

Putin spoke in front of a crowd tens of thousands strong at the Luzhniki World Cup stadium in Moscow, one of the few times he has been seen in public since launching his invasion 23 days ago

Vladimir Putin gave a a tub-thumping address yesterday to tens of thousands of Russians gathered at Moscow’s world cup stadium, celebrating his invasion of Ukraine in 2014 and drumming up support for his new war

Putin fans in the crowd were seen waving banners emblazoned with the letter ‘Z’, which has been adopted as a symbol of the invasion and the Kremlin’s wider aim of restoring national pride through conquest

North Korean leader Kim Jong-un waves at the crowd during a military parade at Kim Il-sung Square in Pyongyang, North Korea, September 9 2021 (file photo)

Pictured: Reverend Billy Graham speaks to a huge congregation at an open-air meeting in London’s Trafalgar Square, during his Greater London Crusade Tour in 1954

The despot took to the stage dressed in a £10,000 Loro Piana jacket – despite his country’s economy crumbling under the weight of Western sanctions – to address a crowd waving Russian national flags and banners marked with the letter ‘Z’, which has become a potent symbol of the invasion.

Putin, who called the rally to mark the anniversary of the last time he attacked Ukraine to annex the Crimea region, spoke of sharing a ‘common destiny’ with Crimeans, of ‘de-Nazifying’ the region in 2014, and of the ‘bravery’ of soldiers currently fighting in Ukraine. He was met with chants of ‘Russia, Russia, Russia.’

Speaking in front of banners that read ‘For a world without Nazism’ and ‘For Russia’ – with the letter ‘Z’ in each picked out in bold – he said: ‘Sevastopol [capital of Crimea] did the right thing when they put up a barrier to neo-Nazis and radicals, which is already happening on other territories.

‘[The] people of Donbass also disagreed with this, and straight-away they organised military operations against [the Nazis]. They were surrounded and shelled by guns, the Ukrainians sent airstrikes against them. This is called genocide,’ he said, repeating his widely-debunked justification for attacking. ‘It is to save people from this suffering and genocide that we launched our military operation.’

Putin then praised troops taking part in his ‘special operation’, who he said are fighting for the ‘universal values’ of all Russians. The words ‘we don’t abandon our own’ were emblazoned on screens around the stadium. Paraphrasing the Bible, he said: ‘There is no greater love than giving up one’s soul for one’s friends.

‘The best confirmation of this is how our guys are fighting during this operation, shoulder to shoulder, helping each other. When it is necessary, they cover each-other as if it was their own brother from bullets. We haven’t had such unity in a long time,’ he said.

Putin used the rally to peddle falsehoods about why the war started and to shill a narrative of Russia’s battlefield success, speaking of ‘how our guys are fighting during this operation, shoulder to shoulder, helping each other’

Putin called the rally to mark the eighth anniversary of ‘annexing’ Crimea, speaking of ‘de-Nazifying’ the peninsula and of debunked claims of ‘genocide’ in the Donbass

A Russian man gestures towards the stage during a rally in Moscow’s World Cup stadium to support Putin’s war on Ukraine, even as his armed forces shell civilian areas of cities

Rally attendees wave Russian flags alongside flags bearing the ‘Z’ symbol, which has become a potent sign of support for the invasion because it is frequently seen painted on symbols

Two banners reading ‘For a world without Nazism’ and ‘For Russia’ – each with the letter ‘Z’ picked out in bold – are seen above the stage as Vladimir Putin arrives to speak to the crowd

Putin is attempting to rally domestic support in Russia to his cause, having faced near-total condemnation from other nations and isolation even from his allies

Russian flags are seen waving inside the Luzhniki Stadium in Moscow, alongside ‘Z’ banners supporting the war in Ukraine during a rally held by President Putin

Putin waves to supporters after finishing speaking during a pro-war rally held on Friday afternoon, in a rare public appearance since the fighting began

People Russian flags during a concert marking eight years since Russia last attacked Ukraine, at Moscow’s Luzhniki Stadium

Putin has faced intense international pressure over his war and disquiet at home, and appears to be trying to bolster his support by hosting mass rallies

Putin delivers a speech during a concert marking the eighth anniversary of Russia’s annexation of Crimea

While thousands of attendees appeared to be genuine fans of Putin, others said they were government workers pressured to come or believed they were going to a concert

PUTIN’S SPEECH

‘For a world without Nazism’ and ‘For Russia’ – with the letter ‘Z’ in each picked out in bold – he said: ‘Sevastopol [capital of Crimea] did the right thing when they put up a barrier to neo-Nazis and radicals, which is already happening on other territories.

‘There is no greater love than giving up one’s soul for one’s friends.

‘It so happened that the start of the special operation coincided, quite by chance, with the birthday of one of our outstanding military leaders, the sainted Fyodor Ushakov, who throughout his brilliant military career never lost a battle,’ said Putin.

‘He once said: ‘These thunderstorms will go to the glory of Russia’. So it was then. So it is today. And so it will always be.’

The event included patriotic songs, including a performance of ‘Made in the U.S.S.R.,’ with the opening lines ‘Ukraine and Crimea, Belarus and Moldova, it’s all my country.’ Moscow police said 200,000 people had attended the event – though the stadium’s capacity is only 81,000.

In a segment of the speech that was initially cut off – but later broadcast on state TV – Putin likened himself to Russian hero Admiral Fyodor Ushakov who famously never lost a battle, in an apparent attempt to boast of his ‘successes’ in Ukraine which in reality has turned into a bloodbath.

‘He once said: ‘These thunderstorms will go to the glory of Russia’. So it was then. So it is today. And so it will always be.’

Ushakov was the supreme Russian commander of his age during the reigns of Catherinne the Great, her son Pavel, and grandson Alexandr I.

The event was held after Russian airstrikes pounded the city of Lviv in the west of Ukraine this morning, with Russia strikes getting closer to NATO-member Poland in Putin’s bloody-minded invasion of his neighbour.

Andriy Sadovyi, mayor of Lviv, said two Russian missiles launched from the Black Sea – likely by warships – had destroyed an aircraft repair facility and a bus garage close to the airport, but there were no immediate reports of casualties because both facilities were shut down. Four incoming missiles were shot down, he added.

Lviv has largely been spared the devastation wreaked by Russia on cities further to the east but is now being dragged into the fighting as Putin’s advance grinds to a halt – forcing his generals to launch long-range strikes on cities in an attempt to weaken their defences and terrorise civilians. Kyiv was also struck in the early hours.

Vladimir Putin used the speech to peddle falsehoods about the last time he attacked Ukraine in 2014, and to repeat lies he has told about the current war – which he continued to call a ‘special military operation’

People watch a broadcast of Russian President Vladimir Putin’s speech during a concert in Moscow on Friday

People hold a banner with letter Z and saying ‘For Russia’ during the pro-war rally in Moscow on Friday

Banners read ‘Russia’ ‘Donbass’ ‘Crimea’ and ‘For President’ as crowds watch a recording of Vladimir Putin’s speech

Russian President Vladimir Putin delivers a speech to crowds inside Moscow’s World Cup stadium on Friday

A military choir performs during a rally in support of Vladimir Putin’s war on Ukraine in Moscow on Friday

Russian President Vladimir Putin is seen on a big screen as he delivers his speech at the concert marking the eighth anniversary of the referendum on the state status of Crimea and Sevastopol and its reunification with Russia, in Moscow, Russia, Friday, March 18, 2022

Russian President Vladimir Putin attends a concert marking the last time he invaded Ukraine, back in 2014

Pictured: Hosts wear a ‘Z’ on their coats as they present the celebration event. The ‘Z’ has become a symbol of pro-Russian nationalism since Putin launched his brutal invasion, as it is painted on many of Moscow’s military vehicles

The made-for-TV rally in Moscow is intended to drum up support for Putin’s war, which has been internationally condemned

Supporters of Russian President Vladimir Putin hold flags and cheer during a pro-war rally in the capital Moscow

Pictured: Crowds are seen outside the stadium on Friday. Moscow police said more than 200,000 people were in and around the Luzhniki stadium for the rally

Russia’s invasion is now grinding into its third week with heavy losses for Moscow, prompting the US warns that Putin will increasingly resort to nuclear threats in order to keep the West out of the conflict because he will no longer be able to rely on the strength of his conventional forces – which will be weakened in the fighting.

Lieutenant General Scott Berrier, director of the Pentagon’s Defense Intelligence Agency, told Congress yesterday: ‘As this war and its consequences slowly weaken Russian conventional strength, Russia likely will increasingly rely on its nuclear deterrent to signal the West and project strength to its internal and external audiences.’

While Berrier specified that the nuclear threats will be directed at the West, he also warned that Russia appears determined to increase its attacks on Ukraine as well – with the aim of forcing Kyiv to sign a peace deal favourable to Moscow rather than accept an embarrassing compromise.

‘Despite greater than anticipated resistance from Ukraine and relatively high losses in the initial phases of the conflict, Moscow appears determined to press forward by using more lethal capabilities until the Ukrainian government is willing to come to terms favourable to Moscow,’ he said.

Smoke rises over the city of Lviv, in western Ukraine, after two Russian cruise missiles hit the city early Friday – destroying an aircraft repair workshop at the airport and a nearby bus garage

Civilians and members of Ukraine’s territorial defence force look on as smoke rises over the city of Lviv, in the west of Ukraine, after Russian cruise missile strikes early on Friday

A Ukrainian civilian, wounded by flying glass from a Russian airstrike, evacuates from an apartment in Kyiv, Ukraine

Ukrainian firefighters extinguish a blaze at a warehouse after bombing by Russian forces in Kyiv

Rescuers work at a site of buildings damaged by a shelling, as Russia’s attack on Ukraine continues, in Kyiv

Ukrainian firefighters extinguish a blaze at a warehouse after a bombing in the capital city of Kyiv

Civilians watch a storage facility go up in flames after it was hit by artillery shelling in the north of Kyiv

A residential building damaged by shelling, as Russia’s attack on Ukraine continues, is seen in Kharkiv, Ukraine

A man with a cat evacuates from a building damaged by shelling, as Russia’s attack on Ukraine continues in Kyiv

Residents of Lviv have told of their shock at the Russian missile attack on their ‘safe-haven’ city. Families living in a housing estate close to the bomb strike described how buildings shook and windows rattled from the explosion.

Professional dancer Anna Malchevska, 25, told MailOnline: ‘I was woken up by the explosions, there were four of them. The windows were shaking and the building was shaking. It must have been about 6 o’clock this morning.

‘There was no warning. No air raid siren, just boom, boom. Then I looked out of the window and there was a huge plume of black smoke.’

Ira Melnyk, 60, who is retired, said: ‘I’m not sleeping at the moment because of all the stress of the war. ‘So when I heard the first explosion I pick up my dog and rushed into the bathroom where it’s safer.

‘The building was shaking and the windows were rattling. It was awful. When I went up the window I could see a plume of black smoke. It was really scary.’

Father Andriy Mousiyiyev told how he no longer takes his children to the bomb shelter after surviving the bombing raids in his home city of Kharkiv. He told MailOnline: ‘We came from Kharkiv where we lived under the bombs for days on end. We thought we had escaped the war when we got here to Lviv about a week ago.

‘But now the war is everywhere. We have young children do we don’t go to the shelter every time the air raid sirens go off. So this morning we were in the flat when the bombs went off. It was about 6.10. The children were not frightened. They just want to go home to Kharkiv, we all do.’

In city after city around Ukraine, hospitals, schools and buildings where people sought safety from the bombardment have been attacked.

Rescue workers searched for survivors in the ruins of a theater that served as a shelter when it was blown apart by a Russian airstrike in the besieged southern city of Mariupol.

And in Merefa, near the northeast city of Kharkiv, at least 21 people were killed when Russian artillery destroyed a school and a community center, a local official said.

In the northern city of Chernihiv, dozens of bodies were brought to the morgue in just one day.

As Russia’s ground advance has stalled under fierce Ukrainian resistance, Moscow has increasingly turned to air and long-range strikes to gain the upper hand.

According to Pentagon estimates, Russia has now fired over 1,000 missiles at Ukrainian targets since the war began three weeks ago.

In the early hours of Friday air raid alarms again rung in cities from Kyiv in the north to Odessa in the south and Kharkiv in the east.

Ukraine’s government listed a kindergarten and market in Kharkiv among the latest targets.

In his latest late-night video message, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky admitted the situation in several Ukrainian cities was ‘difficult.’

But, he said, ‘we will not leave you behind and we will not forgive them. You will be free.’

Hoping to sustain the fight, he has beseeched allies for more assistance – even as an arsenal of anti-tank and anti-aircraft missiles flood into the country.

Slovakia confirmed it is willing to provide powerful Russian-made S-300 anti-aircraft missile system to Ukraine, but only on the condition that it receive a substitute from NATO allies.

On Wednesday Zelensky told German lawmakers that Russia was throwing up another ‘Berlin Wall’, a dividing line between ‘freedom and bondage’ in Europe.

‘And this wall is growing bigger with every bomb,’ he added.

That dividing line is currently drawn around 15 kilometres from Kyiv, where Russian troops are still trying to surround the capital in a slow-moving offensive.

On Wednesday AFP journalists witnessed Ukrainian and Russian forces trade shell and rocket fire to the northwest of the city.

Civilians ran for cover as shelling set fire to a building near a warehouse.

Inside the warehouse’s car park, a Ukrainian soldier carrying a rifle ran in a crouch as gunshots crackled through the air.

A man carried a prone child in his arms into a nearby block of flats, and at least five ambulances raced towards the scene.

An interior view shows a residential building damaged by shelling, as Russia’s attack on Ukraine continues, in Kyiv

Rescuers work next to a residential building damaged by shelling, as Russia’s attack on Ukraine continues, in Kyiv

Smoke rises from the ruins of a building in Sievierodonetsk, in the Ukrainian-held part of eastern Donetsk region, where fighting with Moscow-backed rebel forces is ongoing

A view shows a building of a hospital damaged by shelling as Russia’s attack on Ukraine continues, in Sievierodonetsk

A fire broke out in a residential building in Kyiv’s Podilskyi district after it was struck by a downed Russian missile, with one person killed and four injured

A fire broke out in a residential building in Kyiv’s Podilskyi district as a result of a downed missile

Rescuers work on remains of a residential building damaged by shelling, as Russia’s attack on Ukraine continues, in Kharkiv

Destroyed cars are seen in an area damaged by shelling, as Russia’s attack on Ukraine continues, are seen in Kyiv

Locals walk next to residential buildings damaged by shelling, as Russia’s attack on Ukraine continues, in Kyiv, Ukraine

Residents of a shell-damaged house in Kyiv, Ukraine, clean broken window panes

In Odessa, on the Black Sea, civilians were bracing for attack, with tanks deployed at intersections and monuments covered in sandbags.

‘Our beautiful Odessa,’ said Lyudmila, an elegant elderly woman wearing bright lipstick, as she looked apologetically at her city’s empty, barricaded streets.

‘But thank God we are holding on! Everyone is holding on!’

U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken said Thursday that American officials were evaluating potential war crimes and that if the intentional targeting of civilians by Russia is confirmed, there will be ‘massive consequences.’

The United Nations political chief, Undersecretary-General Rosemary DiCarlo, also called for an investigation into civilian casualties, reminding the U.N. Security Council that international humanitarian law bans direct attacks on civilians.

She said many of the daily attacks battering Ukrainian cities ‘are reportedly indiscriminate’ and involve the use of ‘explosive weapons with a wide impact area.’ DiCarlo said the devastation in Mariupol and Kharkiv ‘raises grave fears about the fate of millions of residents of Kyiv and other cities facing intensifying attacks.’

In Mariupol, hundreds of civilians were said to have taken shelter in a grand, columned theater in the city’s center when it was hit Wednesday by a Russian airstrike. More than a day later, there were no reports of deaths and conflicting reports on whether anyone had emerged from the rubble. Communications are disrupted across the city and movement is difficult because of shelling and other fighting.

Satellite imagery on Monday from Maxar Technologies showed huge white letters on the pavement outside the theater spelling out ‘CHILDREN’ in Russian – ‘DETI’ – to alert warplanes to the vulnerable people hiding inside.

‘We hope and we think that some people who stayed in the shelter under the theater could survive,’ Petro Andrushchenko, an official with the mayor’s office, told The Associated Press. He said the building had a relatively modern basement bomb shelter designed to withstand airstrikes. Other officials said earlier that some people had gotten out.

Video and photos provided by the Ukrainian military showed that the at least three-story building had been reduced to a roofless shell, with some exterior walls collapsed.

Across the city, snow flurries fell around the skeletons of burned, windowless and shrapnel-scarred apartment buildings as smoke rose above the skyline.

‘We are trying to survive somehow,’ said one Mariupol resident, who gave only her first name, Elena. ‘My child is hungry. I don’t know what to give him to eat.’

She had been trying to call her mother, who was in a town 50 miles (80 kilometers) away. ‘I can’t tell her I am alive, you understand. There is no connection, just nothing,’ she said.

Cars, some with the ‘Z’ symbol of the Russian invasion force in their windows, drove past stacks of ammunition boxes and artillery shells in a neighborhood controlled by Russian-backed separatists.

Russia’s military denied bombing the theater or anyplace else in Mariupol on Wednesday.

In Chernihiv, at least 53 people were brought to morgues over 24 hours, killed amid heavy Russian air attacks and ground fire, the local governor, Viacheslav Chaus, told Ukrainian TV on Thursday.

Ukrainian soldiers and firefighters search in a destroyed building after a bombing attack in Kyiv, Ukraine

Members of a Territorial Defense unit guard a defensive position on the outskirts of Kyiv

Ukrainian soldiers take cover from incoming artillery fire in Irpin, the outskirts of Kyiv

Ukraine’s emergency services said a mother, father and three of their children, including 3-year-old twins, were killed when a Chernihiv hostel was shelled. Civilians were hiding in basements and shelters across the embattled city of 280,000.

‘The city has never known such nightmarish, colossal losses and destruction,’ Chaus said.

The World Health Organization said it has verified 43 attacks on hospitals and health facilities, with 12 people killed and 34 injured.

In remarks early Friday, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said he was thankful to President Joe Biden for additional military aid, but he would not get into specifics about the new package, saying he did not want Russia to know what to expect. He said when the invasion began on Feb. 24, Russia expected to find Ukraine much as it did in 2014, when Russia seized Crimea without a fight and backed separatists as they took control of the eastern Donbas region.

Instead, he said, Ukraine had much stronger defenses than expected, and Russia ‘didn’t know what we had for defense or how we prepared to meet the blow.’

In a joint statement, the foreign ministers of the Group of Seven leading economies accused Putin of conducting an ‘unprovoked and shameful war,’ and called on Russia to comply with the International Court of Justice’s order to stop its attack and withdraw its forces.

Both Ukraine and Russia this week reported some progress in negotiations. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said Thursday that some negotiators were breaking into working groups.

Zelenskyy said he would not reveal Ukraine’s negotiating tactics.

‘Working more in silence than on television, radio or on Facebook,’ Zelenskyy said. ‘I consider it the right way.’

While details of Thursday’s talks were unknown, an official in Zelenskyy’s office told the AP that on Wednesday, the main subject discussed was whether Russian troops would remain in separatist regions in eastern Ukraine after the war and where the borders would be.

The official, speaking on condition of anonymity to discuss the sensitive talks, said Ukraine was insisting on the inclusion of one or more Western nuclear powers in the negotiations and on legally binding security guarantees for Ukraine.

In exchange, the official said, Ukraine was ready to discuss a neutral military status.

Russia has demanded that NATO pledge never to admit Ukraine to the alliance or station forces there.he fighting has led more than 3 million people to flee Ukraine, the U.N. estimates. The death toll remains unknown, though Ukraine has said thousands of civilians have died.

Source: Read Full Article